CRMs in mortgage lending often fail not because of bad software—but because they are expected to do things they weren’t designed for. Many lenders change CRMs repeatedly, wasting money on implementations when the real problem is a lack of data strategy and process alignment.
Here’s a checklist for CRM performance evaluation to assess if your CRM is working
Are we clear on what a CRM is actually meant to do?
- A CRM is not a Customer Data Platform (CDP)—it manages customer interactions, not raw data aggregation.
- A CRM does not generate leads—it organizes, tracks, and nurtures them.
- A CRM is only as good as the data and workflows feeding into it.
Do we have a structured data strategy to support the CRM?
- Are we integrating lead sources correctly, or just dumping raw data?
- Are we de-duplicating and cleaning records before they enter the CRM?
- Are we enriching borrower profiles with behavioral insights, not just loan data?
Are we using the CRM for borrower lifecycle tracking, not just lead storage?
- Are we tracking every borrower’s journey (lead → application → closed loan → retention)?
- Are we aligning CRM data with servicing data to predict refinance opportunities?
- Are we scoring and prioritizing leads instead of treating all inquiries equally?
Are loan officers using the CRM, or is it just another system they ignore?
- Are sales teams actively logging interactions, or is the CRM a data graveyard?
- Are lead handoff processes between marketing and sales clearly defined?
- Are we automating follow-ups, or relying on manual inputs that never happen?
Are CRM automation workflows actually driving engagement?
- Are automated emails and text messages converting, or just creating noise?
- Are follow-up sequences personalized based on borrower intent?
- Are we testing different outreach cadences to optimize engagement?
Are we aligning CRM metrics with business goals?
- Are we tracking Cost Per Funded Loan (CPFL) within CRM reports?
- Are we measuring CRM-driven borrower retention, not just acquisition?
- Are we identifying drop-off points in the loan life cycle and optimizing them?
Are we segmenting borrowers for tailored communication?
- Are we grouping leads by loan type, credit profile, and rate sensitivity?
- Are we customizing messaging for first-time buyers vs. repeat refinancers?
- Are we suppressing irrelevant messaging to avoid disengagement?
Are we integrating CRM data with marketing and analytics platforms?
- Are we feeding CRM data into analytics tools for performance tracking?
- Are we leveraging CRM insights to optimize digital ad targeting?
- Are we syncing CRM contacts with email and direct mail platforms seamlessly?
Are we maximizing CRM-driven retention strategies?
- Are we proactively identifying borrowers at risk of refinancing elsewhere?
- Are we triggering outreach based on rate movement or home equity changes?
- Are we tracking long-term borrower engagement beyond the initial loan?
Are we solving CRM inefficiencies, or just planning to replace it?
- Are we constantly switching CRMs instead of fixing integration issues?
- Are we optimizing workflows before blaming the software?
- Are we investing in CRM training to ensure teams are using it correctly?
Final Thought:
Your CRM isn’t broken—it just needs a structured data strategy, clear workflows, and integration with the right platforms. Before considering another expensive migration, use this checklist for CRM performance to allow the system to work for you, not the other way around.